If you discover defects shortly before settlement, first identify whether you are buying an established property under a sale contract or arranging a practical completion inspection (PCI) of newly constructed work. The available remedies and inspection scope can differ. An independent inspection can document visible concerns, but your conveyancer or solicitor should advise which issues the contract requires the other party to address. A detailed pre-settlement inspection report, with photos, exact locations and the trade responsible for each item, turns a vague complaint into a short list of fixes someone has to sign off. Here is how that process works in practice, and where buyers usually lose ground.
Table of Contents
- Quick Takeaways
- What a Pre-Settlement Inspection Can and Cannot Do
- How to Document Defects So They Are Hard to Argue With
- Classifying Defects So the Serious Ones Lead
- Building Your Negotiation Position Before Settlement
- Comparing Negotiation Outcomes: Repair, Credit or Price Cut
- Putting Agreed Fixes in Writing With Your Conveyancer
- Timing Your Inspection Around Settlement Day
- Frequently Asked Questions
- References
Quick Takeaways
| Key Insight | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Plan the inspection timing with your conveyancer | Queensland Government suggests a final condition check two to three days before settlement. This does not guarantee time for repairs; the appropriate timing and access depend on the contract and the inspection type. |
| Every defect needs a photo, a location and a description | Verbal complaints are easy to dismiss. A numbered photo tied to a room and element is much harder to argue with. |
| Identify the likely trade where reasonably clear | When the report says who should fix what, the builder or developer cannot pass the item between subcontractors. |
| Lead with structural and water-related defects | These carry the most weight. Once they are agreed, the cosmetic list is far easier to settle. |
| Record agreed commitments in writing and seek legal advice | Record proposed fixes and dates in writing, and have your conveyancer or solicitor advise on how to make any agreement enforceable under your contract. |
| Discuss repair or credit options with your conveyancer | A credit that is not tied to a realistic cost gets rejected. A quoted figure gives the seller a clear choice. |
What a Pre-Settlement Inspection Can and Cannot Do
A final condition check before settlement usually focuses on whether the property is in the condition required by the sale contract. A separate pre-purchase building inspection or new-build PCI is a more detailed assessment with a different agreed scope. Confirm which inspection you need before booking. DK Legal’s pre-settlement checklist describes it as your final opportunity to confirm the property and any included items are in the condition they were in when you signed, fair wear and tear excepted. Keep that framing in mind, because it shapes every conversation that follows.
In practice, the inspection tends to uncover three kinds of problem. The first is work that was promised but never finished, such as a missing balustrade, an incomplete tiling job or a fixture still in its packaging. The second is defects logged at the pre-handover inspection that were never rectified. The third is damage that appeared during the final stages of construction, through removalists, or from trades moving through the site. Anything that existed before you signed is harder to bring back into play now, so your report should clearly separate new issues from old ones.
Where the contract sets the limits
Your contract and any special conditions decide what the seller is obliged to fix. Read them before the inspection, not after. If a defect falls under a specific clause, cite that clause in your report. If you are unsure whether an issue is covered, ask your conveyancer or solicitor before you send anything to the seller, because a vague demand can stall the whole settlement.
What new home inspections usually turn up
New homes tend to produce a predictable mix of findings. Doors that do not latch, chipped tiles, uneven paintwork, sealant gaps in wet areas, and cabinet doors out of alignment are all common. Some of these are cosmetic, but they still count when you are asking for them to be fixed before handover is complete. List them in the same structured way as the serious items, so the seller cannot dismiss the whole report as nitpicking.
How to Document Defects So They Are Hard to Argue With
Clear photographs and descriptions can help a seller or builder understand the findings; whether rectification is required depends on the contract and relevant obligations. A sentence saying the kitchen looks poor does nothing. A photo of a cabinet door sitting visibly out of line, with the room and unit recorded, is very hard to dispute. That is why GoInspect builds its defect reports around photographs, so the builder, the developer or your conveyancer can check every item without a second site visit.
Photos that prove location and scale
Take a wide shot that shows where the defect sits in the room, then a close shot of the defect itself. Include a reference point such as a door frame, power point or floor junction so the trade can find it without guessing. Number each photo and match it to a line in the report. When the list reaches the seller, each line should stand on its own.
Pro tip: Photograph surface defects in daylight, then again with a torch held low across the surface. Raking light makes scratches, dents and uneven finishes show up clearly, while they can look invisible in a flat photo.
Writing each defect so a tradesperson can act on it
Each line should name the room, the element, the defect and the trade responsible. ‘Bathroom, shower screen, silicone gap at the base, plumber’ gets a response. ‘Bathroom not finished’ does not. Assigning a specific trade matters because it stops the builder from treating the item as someone else’s problem. Same-day reporting also helps, since questions and answers move quickly while the inspection details are still fresh.
Classifying Defects So the Serious Ones Lead
Not every defect deserves the same negotiation. The Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) divides defective building work into two broad groups. Structural defects are work that adversely affects structural performance, affects the health or safety of occupants, affects the functional use of a building, or allows water penetration. Non-structural defects are work that does not meet a reasonable standard of construction or finish expected of a competent licensed contractor, or that has caused a settling-in period defect in a new building.
Leading your report with structural and water-related items changes the tone of the whole negotiation. The seller understands quickly that these are not items they can wave away. The cosmetic list then becomes much easier to discuss once the serious items are agreed.
Structural defects and water penetration
Water penetration, cracked lintels, windows or doors that do not seal, and balcony waterproofing problems belong at the top of the list. Ask for an explanation of the cause, not just the symptom. If your inspector has flagged something that may need a specialist, say so in the report and recommend the next step rather than guessing at the fix.
The reasonable standard test
For non-structural items, the question is whether the work meets a reasonable standard of construction or finish. The QBCC’s worked example on painting shows how specific this can get. Nail fixings or unfilled depressions in painted surfaces count as defects when they can be seen from a normal viewing position and the complaint is made within the first 12 months after completion. A benchmark like that gives you a neutral reference point rather than a personal opinion about how a wall looks.
Settling-in period defects in new builds
New homes go through a settling-in period, and minor cracking, sticking doors and gaps can appear as the structure moves. The QBCC recognises settling-in period defects in new buildings as their own category. Do not assume every hairline crack is a settling issue, and do not assume the builder will accept that label automatically. Photograph the crack, record its width where you can, and note whether it has changed since your last visit.
Building Your Negotiation Position Before Settlement
A negotiation position is a ranked list with a clear request for each item. Sellers and developers respond to specific requests far faster than open-ended complaints. Before you send anything, decide which items are must-fix, which are should-fix, and which you can accept if the seller gives a written commitment on the rest.
Ranking the list into must-fix and should-fix
Must-fix items are structural, water-related, safety-related, and anything that stops the home being used as intended, such as a door that will not lock or an appliance that is not connected. Should-fix items are the finish issues that still matter to the standard you paid for. Put the must-fix items first in your covering email and keep the list to a handful of points. A short list is easier to agree to.
Costing the options and what a credit should cover
Where a seller does not want to carry out work before settlement, a monetary credit becomes the alternative. A credit only works if the number is realistic. Get a quote from a qualified trade for each item, include the cost of any follow-up visit, and offer the seller the choice between completing the work and accepting a credit of equal value. An unsupported figure may delay agreement, so obtain appropriate quotes and legal advice before proposing any contractual adjustment.
Keep a complete, dated defect list, and ask your conveyancer or solicitor how any proposed settlement arrangement should be recorded.
Comparing Negotiation Outcomes: Repair, Credit or Price Cut
Depending on the contract and the parties’ agreement, possible outcomes may include repairs, a negotiated credit or a price adjustment. Ask your conveyancer or solicitor whether any option is available and appropriate.
| Approach | How it works | Where it fits best |
|---|---|---|
| Seller completes repairs before settlement | The builder or seller arranges trades to return and fix listed items, then you re-inspect and sign off. | Quick fixes such as adjustments, touch-ups and fittings that can be done within the settlement window. |
| Monetary credit at settlement | An agreed amount is credited to you at settlement, and you arrange the repair with your own contractor. | Larger jobs, or situations where the trades cannot return before the settlement date. |
| Price reduction only | The purchase price is cut with no commitment to fix the defect. | May suit some negotiated settlements, depending on the contract, repair scope and independent legal advice. |
Why a price cut is the weakest opening
A price reduction hands the seller a number and walks away from the fix. You are left with the defect, the cost, and no guarantee the work ever happens. A price adjustment may be one option where the parties agree and the contract permits it. Discuss the implications with your conveyancer before proposing or accepting a change.
When a credit beats a repair
A credit makes sense when the builder’s trades cannot return before settlement, or when you want the work done by a contractor you choose to a standard you specify. The downside is that a credit must be accurate. Take the quote seriously and make sure it covers the full scope of the problem, not just the visible part.
Putting Agreed Fixes in Writing With Your Conveyancer
Record any proposed resolution in writing and have your conveyancer or solicitor check how it should be documented under your contract. Whether a verbal agreement has legal effect depends on the circumstances; do not rely on informal assurances alone.
What the written agreement should list
Each agreed item needs a description, the room or location, the agreed action, the responsible party and a completion date. If a credit is agreed, state the amount and when it will be paid. Your conveyancer or solicitor should review the wording before you sign, because those written terms are what you will rely on after settlement.
Pro tip: Put a re-inspection date in the written agreement and book it before settlement. A follow-up inspection can document whether the agreed work appears complete, but enforceability depends on the agreement and contract.
When the seller refuses or stalls
If the seller refuses everything, do not start by threatening to walk away. Ask your conveyancer to explain your contract options first, because a wrong move at this stage can cost you time and money. Often the most effective step is to narrow the list to the structural and water-related items and present those again in writing, with photos and trade attribution attached. Any proposed retention or change to settlement funds needs your solicitor’s advice and the necessary agreement; do not withhold payment unilaterally. Whether that is available depends entirely on your contract, so ask early rather than on settlement morning.
Timing Your Inspection Around Settlement Day
Timing is the factor buyers underestimate most. DK Legal’s checklist suggests doing the final inspection at least 48 to 72 hours before settlement, which gives your lawyer time to act without causing a delay. In practice, the window between practical completion and settlement can be tighter than buyers expect, so plan for it from the start of the process.
Booking the inspection window
Book the inspection when the property is clear of furniture and construction debris, ideally in daylight. Allow enough time to walk every room, check external areas, test taps and doors, and photograph everything. Rushing a pre-settlement inspection is how small defects get missed, and missed items are much harder to raise once you have the keys.
Same-day reporting and what it makes possible
GoInspect delivers reports on the same day, so the list can reach your conveyancer and the seller while there is still time to act. For current inspection scope and a property-specific fee, use our quotes and bookings form. Findings can be organised by location and relevant trade for follow-up. Customised reports for high-rise developments and housing projects also let developers and builders see issues in the same format buyers receive. For buyers across Brisbane, the Gold Coast, Logan, Ipswich and Redland Bay, that speed often decides whether a defect is fixed before settlement or argued about after it.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long before settlement should I book a pre-settlement inspection?
Aim for at least two to three days before settlement. This is Queensland Government guidance for a final condition check; it does not guarantee time for rectification or reinspection. Discuss access, any new-build PCI timing, and contract requirements with your conveyancer. Booking too close to settlement leaves no room to fix anything, while booking too early means new issues can appear before you take ownership.
Can I refuse to settle if the defects are not fixed?
Do not make that decision on your own. Refusing to settle can have serious contract consequences, so contact your conveyancer or solicitor immediately if you find a significant issue, as DK Legal’s guide advises. They can assess your options under your contract before you take any step.
Do I need a detailed report to negotiate defect rectification?
A detailed report is not strictly required, but it is far more persuasive than verbal complaints. Photos, locations, a clear description of each defect and the responsible trade leave the seller little to dispute except the fix itself. That shifts the conversation from whether a defect exists to how quickly it will be corrected.
Is a seller obliged to fix cosmetic defects?
It depends on what the contract requires, which is why the wording matters. Items that were defective at contract signing, or work that was promised but not finished, are generally easier to pursue than ordinary wear and tear, which contracts usually exclude. Your conveyancer can confirm where a specific item sits.
How much does a GoInspect pre-settlement inspection cost?
Fees depend on the property and inspection type. Request a current quote through our booking form. Our photo-based reports document visible and accessible findings; discuss timing and scope before booking.
For a new-build practical completion inspection, see our handover inspection information and confirm the agreed inspection scope before booking.